The Fed Matters… But Maybe a Little Less Than It Used To

The relationship between the Federal Reserve’s monetary policy decisions and the equity market is significant for investors to understand.  At its core, this connection is driven by expectations.

The Federal Reserve, often referred to as the Fed, plays a critical role in the United States economy by setting short-term interest rates, which influence borrowing costs.  When the Fed changes interest rates, it directly impacts economic activity, influencing everything from inflation rates to employment levels.  Consequently, the equity market responds to changes in expectations regarding what the Fed will do because investors are trying to anticipate the Fed’s impact on the economy and, by extension, on corporate profits.

When the Fed is expected to raise interest rates, the cost of borrowing increases.  For businesses, this translates to higher expenses for financing operations and expansions, potentially reducing their profitability.  Higher interest rates also make fixed-income investments more attractive relative to equities, leading some investors to shift their portfolios away from stocks.  Further, consumer spending can slow down as loans for major purchases become more expensive, adversely affecting corporate revenues.

Conversely, expectations of a rate cut can stimulate the equity market as cheaper borrowing costs can lead to increased spending and investment.

Last week, US inflation numbers came in higher than expected and this has injected additional volatility into the equity market for several reasons.  

First, higher than expected inflation typically prompts the Fed to consider raising interest rates, or at the very least, delay cutting interest rates.  The prospect of higher rates for longer can lead to uncertainty among investors, as the potential impacts on corporate earnings and economic growth are reassessed.  

Second, high inflation erodes the purchasing power of consumers, affecting the revenue of companies, especially those directly selling to consumers.  The unpredictability of Fed rates contributes to market volatility, as investors recalibrate their expectations for growth and interest rates.

However, with interest rates having risen substantially since before the pandemic and now sitting at more normal levels by historical standards, one might question why markets continue to react so aggressively to changes in interest rate expectations.

The heightened sensitivity to interest rate expectations in the period before and during the pandemic was due to the exceptionally low rates that followed the 2008 financial crisis.  During this time, investors grew accustomed to cheap borrowing costs, which supported higher valuations in equity markets.

As rates return to more historically normal levels, the market’s reaction to changes in rate expectations should, in theory, moderate.  This normalization suggests that businesses and investors will adapt to a higher interest rate environment, and their future decisions will be made with a more balanced view of potential financing costs.

Looking forward, this narrative suggests a future less dominated by the Fed’s actions and interest rate changes.  As markets adjust to the current interest rate environment, the direct impact of minor adjustments in policy by the Fed is likely to diminish.

This reduction in market sensitivity to changes in interest rate expectations is good news.  Less focus on the Fed’s every move allows for a broader assessment of economic fundamentals, corporate performance, and other long-term growth drivers.  It encourages investment decisions based on a comprehensive analysis of company value and potential, rather than speculative reactions to anticipated policy shifts.

Moreover, a more stable and predictable interest rate environment can foster long-term investment and economic planning, contributing to sustainable economic growth.  Businesses can make investment decisions with greater certainty about financing costs, while consumers can make major purchases without fearing abrupt changes in borrowing costs.  

For equity markets, a reduced emphasis on the Fed’s policy moves can lead to lower volatility, allowing investors to focus on fundamentals and long-term prospects rather than short-term policy speculation.

So, while the Fed’s policies and interest rate decisions will always be important factors for the equity market, the evolving economic landscape suggests a future where these elements play a less dominant role.

As interest rates stabilize at more historical norms, the market’s over-sensitivity to the Fed’s actions should diminish, leading to a more balanced and fundamentally driven investment environment.  This shift is poised to benefit the economy and equity markets, paving the way for more sustainable growth and stability.

Links: Post | Image